Is it worth fixing an ice maker?

Author: Emmett Hoeger  |  Last update: Wednesday, July 23, 2025

Should I repair or replace my ice maker? The cost to repair and replace ice makers is so similar that it's often more beneficial to just replace the ice maker. Replacing it means the new ice maker will last longer than a repair for nearly the same price.

What is the average life of an ice maker?

Sadly, with every piece of equipment comes a lifespan. With proper cleaning, a quality ice machine will last around 4 to 5 years on average, sometimes even longer. So how do you know when it's time to replace your ice machine? The first thing you need to do is locate the problem.

What is the average cost to repair an ice maker?

The national average cost range to repair an ice maker is $150 to $250. Most homeowners pay around $200 to fix a leaking, freestanding ice maker. The low cost for this project is $75 to replace a valve on a portable ice maker. The cost is $400 to replace the motor on a high-end, built-in ice maker.

Is it worth it to fix an ice maker?

Deciding to fix an ice maker depends on the age of the appliance, the repair cost, and the ice maker problem. For a newer ice maker with a minor issue, a repair is likely worth it. If your ice maker or fridge is old and the repair is expensive, replacing the ice maker or even the whole fridge might be the best option.

How do I know if I need a new ice maker?

7 Signs Of An Ice Maker Going Bad
  • Slow Ice Production. ...
  • Noisy Operation. ...
  • Frequent Repairs. ...
  • Outdated Or Inefficient Model. ...
  • Leaks & Water Problems. ...
  • Aesthetic Considerations. ...
  • Poor Ice Quality.

Ice Maker Not Working? - Check these 6 Things first!

How often should you replace your ice maker?

We typically recommend a replacement once an ice machine is 7 years or older.

What happens when ice maker stops working?

There are several reasons your ice maker may suddenly stop working, including a blocked water dispenser, issues with your water supply line or a clogged water filter.

What is the most expensive thing to fix on a refrigerator?

Compressor Issues

The compressor is like the heart of your fridge. If it breaks, it's one of the most expensive parts to replace. Fixing a compressor can cost anywhere from $200 to $650.

Can an ice maker be repaired?

If your ice maker is not working, start by doing a quick troubleshooting for the problems mentioned above. Many of these can be fixed by yourself, such as adjusting the thermostat, cleaning the water filter, and even replacing some easily accessible parts as long as you feel comfortable doing so.

How much does it cost to replace the valve on an ice maker?

The water valve controls the water that flows into the ice maker's cube mold by turning it on and off. It can break and potentially cause leaks. A new water valve will cost around $20, and replacing it will cost $75 to $175, including labor.

How do I know if my ice maker is bad?

The Machine Is Leaking Water. If your ice machine is leaking water, it could be a sign that there is a problem with the seals or gaskets. These are designed to keep the water in the machine, and if they are damaged, it can cause the machine to leak water.

Which brand of refrigerator is the best?

Our Top Pick: LG produces excellent refrigerators that perform well in our tests and receive high satisfaction ratings from consumers, including our survey participants. The Smart French Door Refrigerator with Dual Ice Maker stands out for its simple, user-friendly design and customizable features.

Do you need a plumber to install an ice maker?

You will have to get a licensed plumber, or someone who is extremely adept in plumbing work to tap into the cold water pipe, install a shut-off valve, and run a length of, preferably, copper tubing to the rear of the refrigerator.

Is it okay to leave ice maker on all the time?

If the unit is powered off the ice will melt and the water will return to the reservoir. This is just like your refrigerator or freezer in that it needs to be on all the time.

Do ice makers wear out?

As an industry standard, the average life of a commercial ice machine is around 10 years, however there are a few variables that will affect the life of your ice machine. uncommon to take calls about machines that are 15 plus years old that are still running strong.

Who makes the best countertop ice maker?

Our Top Countertop Ice Maker Picks
  • Best Overall. Iceman by Chefman Dual-Size Countertop Ice Maker. ...
  • Best Value. AGLUCKY Countertop Ice Maker. ...
  • Best Splurge. GE Profile Opal 2.0 Countertop Ice Maker with Side Tank. ...
  • Best Compact. Iceman by Chefman Compact Portable Ice Maker. ...
  • Best Nugget. Ecozy Countertop Nugget Ice Maker. ...
  • Best Smart.

Is it worth replacing an ice maker?

You should repair your ice maker if it's less than 5 years old, under warranty, or if new parts are affordable. Replace your unit if it's an older model, or if the repair costs more than replacing the whole ice maker assembly.

Why does my water work but not my ice maker?

The ice maker or dispenser could be jammed or broken, a dirty water filter or kinked water line could be blocking water flow or the water inlet valve could be clogged or faulty.

Does unplugging a refrigerator reset the ice maker?

If you don't hear a chime, but you can see movement from the ice maker, then the ice maker was reset. If you don't hear a chime and there is no movement from the ice maker, unplug the fridge or turn it off at the circuit breaker for 2 minutes. Then, power it back up and try again.

Is it worth fixing a fridge or buying a new one?

One factor to consider is the age of your refrigerator. If it's more than fifteen years old, it may not be worth repairing because the cost of parts and labor may be more than that of a new fridge. However, if your fridge is under the fifteen-year mark, it's almost always worth the cost of repair.

What is the most expensive fridge part?

While there are many components within a refrigerator that could potentially fail, one of the most costly repairs is replacing the compressor. The compressor is the heart of the refrigeration cycle, the part that pushes refrigerant through the coils to cool the inside of the fridge.

Which refrigerator has the fewest repairs?

All three of the appliance experts we spoke to for this roundup said Whirlpool and LG were the most reliable refrigerator brands due to their durability, reliability and ease of repairs. Samsung and GE were also mentioned by our experts as high-quality fridges.

Why is my ice maker running but not making ice?

Your freezer temperature could be too high, the water inlet valve may not be functioning correctly, your home water pressure may be low, the refrigerator's water filter may be clogged, or the ice maker may need to be replaced.

How do I fix my ice maker?

Troubleshooting Your Ice Maker
  1. ​1. Check the Temperature Settings. ...
  2. Clogged Water Filter. If the water filter in your refrigerator is not changed regularly, this can stop water flow. ...
  3. Frozen Water Supply Tube. ...
  4. ​Turn the switch on and off. ...
  5. Check the Water Supply Line. ...
  6. Faulty Door Switch. ...
  7. After Market Filters.

Previous article
Does mould wipe away easily?
Next article
What is the best cleaner for dirty wood cabinets?