Synthetic underlayment is a high-tech alternative to traditional tar paper. It is made of polypropylene or polyester fabric that is saturated or coated with asphalt. Compared to traditional tar paper, synthetic underlayment is stronger, more durable, and more resistant to tears and punctures.
There are various types of roofing underlayment or underlayment materials. In the past, tar-paper was the standard, and I still occasionally come across old roofs that have it. However, today, fiberglass felt (sometimes called felt paper) and polypropylene/polyethylene are the industry standard.
For enhanced water-resistance and protection from the elements, many roofers are choosing to go the route of synthetic roofing underlayment. These products are usually made from long-lasting polymers, which provide added strength and longevity.
The building codes where I work require that felt paper be used. If you do not put felt paper under the shingles and they find out, they will force you too tear off the shingles and put felt paper down. The contractor is charged with the bill. So it is a big yes to putting tar paper down.
#1 GAF FeltBuster® Synthetic Roofing Felt
If you're looking for a durable, synthetic underlayment that works well with asphalt shingles, GAF FeltBuster is a solid choice. It's from one of the most trusted names in roofing, GAF, so you know it's a product built to last. Pros: Lightweight and easy to install.
Also known as tar paper or a felt underlayment, this material offers some benefits for roof protection. But once the roof is complete, felt fails to make your home more waterproof. This is especially important for those of us living in rainy climates, such as Portland, OR, and the greater Pacific Northwest.
Remember, roof underlayment protects your decking if water ever gets underneath your roofing material. Without underlayment, this water eventually rots your roof decking leading to leaks, mold/mildew forming, and even structural damage.
The Purpose of Tar Paper
Protection During Construction: It safeguards your roof from the elements until the shingle installation is complete. Enhanced Durability: By preventing moisture from reaching the wood, tar paper extends the overall lifespan of your roof.
Without the protective layer of roofing felt, your plywood layer may start to leak resin that could reach up through your shingles and stain your roof.
You need to put down a synthetic felt (which is like tar paper; they come in 4-foot rolls and are made out of paper, tar, oil, and other things) or underlayment, and you want to put that down before you put the tiles down.
Material Composition: Tyvek is a synthetic, while tar paper is an organic material saturated with asphalt. Breathability: Tyvek offers superior breathability. Durability Against UV: Tyvek is more UV-resistant. Weight and Ease of Installation: Tyvek is lighter and generally easier to install with less risk of tearing.
It comes in two different weights: 15- and 30-pound, with 30-pound being the more durable, heavy option. Synthetic roofing underlayment is typically made from durable polymers that are created to be water-resistant and easy to work with. Many roofing contractors prefer to use synthetic roofing underlayment over felt.
After all, the smallest mistake can cause the biggest mishaps for your roofing system and yourself as the homeowner. With that in mind, when replacing your roof, one of the things that you should make sure will be done is to completely remove and replace the old underlayment.
Quality paper handles brief periods of exposure to rain and moisture. However, prolonged exposure can compromise its integrity and effectiveness.
Tar paper, roofing paper, felt paper, underlayment, or roofing tar paper is a heavy-duty paper used in construction. Tar paper is made by impregnating paper with tar, producing a waterproof material useful for roof construction.
Directly beneath the shingles is something called “underlayment,” also known as “roofing felt.” As you may have guessed, underlayment is usually either made of fiberglass paper or felt. It covers the entire roof deck.
Alternatives to roofing felt include synthetic underlayments and EPDM rubber roofing, both offering unique advantages.
The answer is both yes and no. Technically, no, underlayment isn't 100% necessary underneath asphalt shingles. At least, not in areas unregulated by code! Building codes vary from one region to the next, and most all building codes require felt or synthetic roofing underlayment.
Asphalt-Saturated Felt
Asphalt-saturated felt, also known as tar paper, is a traditional option for roof underlayment. It consists of paper or fiberglass mats soaked in asphalt, creating a waterproof layer. This underlayment is known for its reliability and affordability.
Synthetic underlayments are an excellent choice for metal roofing installations. If installed according to manufacturer recommendations, they're more durable than felt products and simpler to install. Owens Corning offers homeowners a choice of synthetic underlayments for their metal roofing system.
Works well for underlayments: When it comes to securing roof underlayments, such as roofing tar paper, staples get the job done with precision and durability. Less prone to jamming: Staple guns often jam up less than nail guns, which means you can complete the project quickly.
Traditional felt underlayment, also known as tar paper, is generally rated to withstand exposure to the elements for a short period of around 30 to 90 days. On the other hand, modern synthetic underlayments are engineered for extended exposure, with some brands claiming to remain effective for six months to a year.
Yes, there are different types of plywood underlayment, including: Premium sanded: Because the surface is sanded, it provides for an even and smooth surface. Both RoyOMartin's SmartCore AC Plywood and SmartCore BC Plywood meets underlayment requirements.
House Wrap Cons
Not designed for use on roofs, where it may not provide adequate protection.
On new roofs, we recommend purchasing exterior grade plywood or waterproof chipboard as a suitable surface to rest on your treated timber joints. Any mortar removal or more detailed preparation should be done in advance of your felt roof project.