Should I replace both garage door springs when one breaks?

Author: Alexandria Rogahn  |  Last update: Friday, November 28, 2025

Make sure you always replace both springs when they snap, regardless of which side snapped first. A broken spring without a repaired or replaced second spring can be problematic – as the garage door will now be subject to extra pressure on only one side.

Should I replace both garage door springs at the same time?

Most garage door companies will offer a better price if you choose to replace both springs at the same time, so as far as cost is concerned replacing both springs is often a smart long-term financial move but it is not necessary if you prefer a lower cost up-front.

Can I use my garage door if one spring is broken?

PROFESSIONAL INSTALLATION AND REPAIR IS RECOMMENDED. Garage doors with broken springs should not be opened. Doors in this condition can be difficult to lift because the garage door opener loses the support springs provide in lifting and lowering the door.

Does my garage door need 1 or 2 springs?

A garage door typically has one to four springs, depending on the size and weight. For example, residential single-car garages are often single-spring garage doors and residential two-car garages are often dual-spring garage doors. But a commercial garage door with many panels might need up to four.

How much does it cost to replace 2 garage door springs?

Breaking Down the Cost of Spring Replacement

To help you understand the costs more easily, here's a simple guide based on the number of springs your garage door uses: 1 spring: $250 – $350 (usually for single-car garage doors) 2 springs: $350 – $500 (typically for double-car garage doors) 3 springs: $450 – $650.

How Much Does a Garage Door Torsion Spring Replacement Cost in 2025?

What is the lifespan of a garage door spring?

When properly installed, your springs can last approximately 10,000 cycles. One cycle includes both the opening and closing of the door. Technically speaking, your springs should last between 7 to 10 years. However, this depends on how often you use your garage door.

Can you lift a garage door with a broken spring?

As professionals in the industry, we advise you do not attempt to open your garage door if the spring is broken.

Can I replace a garage door spring myself?

Replacing a garage door spring yourself isn't impossible, but it does require special knowledge about the springs and how a garage door works.

How long does it take to replace 2 garage door springs?

The time it takes to replace a garage door spring depends on factors such as the type of spring, accessibility, and the skill level of the person performing the replacement. On average, a professional technician can complete the replacement in about one to two hours.

Why does my garage door spring keep breaking?

Garage door springs are constantly exposed to environmental factors such as temperature changes, humidity, and moisture. These factors can cause corrosion, which weakens the spring and ultimately leads to its failure.

How often do springs break on garage doors?

Wear and Tear Over Time

On average, garage door springs are rated for 10,000 cycles, which translates to about 7-10 years of regular use for most households. For homeowners who use their garage as the primary entrance, the springs may wear out even faster.

Why does my garage door have two different springs?

Q) Why do I have two different sized springs on my garage door? A) Torsion Springs may be mismatched from the factory or from a previous replacement.

Should both coil springs be replaced in pairs?

After many millions of cycles, even the best-made springs become 'tired' and eventually the springs will shorten (sag) causing the vehicle ride height to drop. When replacing coil springs is it advisable, for safety and comfort, to always replace in axle pairs. Failure to do so can result in: Uneven ride height.

How to tell if garage door springs need to be replaced?

Here are five signs that a set of springs is ready to go.
  1. You Hear the Garage Door Opener Strain. ...
  2. The Door Slams Shut Without Warning. ...
  3. You Hear a Loud Popping Sound When the Door Is Closed. ...
  4. The Door Feels Heavier. ...
  5. You Can't Rest the Door in the Mid-Level Position.

How to get garage door up with a broken spring?

6 Steps To Opening Garage Door with Broken Spring
  1. Step 1: Disconnect the Garage Door Opener. Locate the emergency release handle on the garage door opener. ...
  2. Step 2: Secure the Door. ...
  3. Step 3: Have Helpers. ...
  4. Step 4: Lift the Door Manually. ...
  5. Step 5: Lift in Sections. ...
  6. Step 6: Secure the Open Door.

Should both garage door springs be replaced?

Make sure you always replace both springs when they snap, regardless of which side snapped first. A broken spring without a repaired or replaced second spring can be problematic – as the garage door will now be subject to extra pressure on only one side.

How much should I pay to replace garage door springs?

Expect to spend $120–$350 to replace your garage door spring, including material costs and professional installation. While these heavy-duty springs are built to last, they'll eventually need replacement due to wear and tear. Garage door spring replacement isn't your average DIY project, either.

How many turns on a 7ft garage door spring?

A 7 ft tall garage door with a standard 12 inch drum, will require 29-30 quarter turns on the spring. An 8 ft garage door with a standard 12 inch drum, will require 33-34 quarter turns on the spring.

How long should a spring on a garage door last?

Many modern garage doors use a torsion spring, lasting about 10,000 open and closing cycles. So, if you use your garage door three times a day, your springs will last about 10 years.

How to buy the correct garage door spring?

Determining the appropriate torsion spring for your garage door system is based on a few factors that include:
  1. Wire Size.
  2. Inside Diameter.
  3. Overall length.
  4. Wind Direction.
  5. Weight of Garage Door.

What happens if you put the wrong spring on a garage door?

A Door That Falls Off Its Tracks – Whether your new springs are too strong, too weak or just not the right type, one possible consequence is that they could derail your door, i.e. cause it to fall off its tracks. In such an event, anybody standing in the garage or just outside could be in very serious danger.

Will the garage door fall if spring breaks?

The door will become crooked when attempting to raise. The garage door could fall quickly. Most of the time you'll notice a bend at the top of the door. Attempting to open the door with the operator will cause more damage.

How hard is it to replace springs on a garage door?

Its a bit tricky the torsion springs are wound under considerable tension. If you slip you can have a serious gash from the tool. I always leave it to a professional since this is a once every 10–20 year repair and can be very dangerous if you don't do it just right.

What happens when a garage door spring is broken?

The garage door will fall quickly as it no longer has a counterbalance for the gravity's pull on the panels. The door will be crooked when it moves up and down the track. Although the door opens, it won't be even. The cable will be loose amongst other issues with broken springs.

Previous article
How do you fix a pantry moth infestation?
Next article
Why does my dishwasher take 3 hours to run?