Which is better, oil or latex stain?

Author: Joshua Eichmann  |  Last update: Monday, February 17, 2025

Oil stains were traditionally the best, but now with the improved waterborne technology you can often get the same results or better with latex acrylics. An added benefit to these products is a soap and water clean up and decreased harm to your landscaping and shrubbery.

What is the disadvantage of oil-based stains?

Longer Drying Time

One of the most significant drawbacks of oil-based stains is their extended drying time. Unlike acrylic stains that can dry within an hour, oil stains can take anywhere from 12 to 24 hours to dry completely.

When should I use oil based stain?

If you live in an area with extreme weather conditions, you should use an oil-based stain. Type of wood: Some woods, such as pine and fir are more prone to rot and mildew than others. These wood products are better protected with an oil-based finish.

What lasts longer, water-based or oil-based stains?

In general, water-based stains are more durable compared to oil-based stains. You need to reconsider your requirements and maintenance to keep the stains in the best of health.

What are the disadvantages of decking oil?

Disadvantages of decking oil:
  • Decking oil is not suitable for all types of timber so you'll need to double check it's suitable for the timber used on your deck.
  • Need to reapply every 4-6 months in a fully exposed environment.

OIL-BASED stain or WATER-BASED stain? Which SHOULD you choose?

Is it better to use decking oil or stain?

An oil penetrates into the wood, enhancing the natural appearance, colour and strength of the natural wood whereas decking stains covers the top of the wood, creating a temporary barrier on the surface of the wood as well as adding colour to the woods surface, minimising the natural appearance of the wood.

What stain is best for an outdoor deck?

2024's Top 15 Deck Stains: Revive and Safeguard Your Deck
  • Cabot Australian Timber Oil - Best Overall Deck Stain.
  • Ready Seal Natural Cedar - Best Budget Deck Stain.
  • Thompsons WaterSeal Advanced - Best Water-Based Deck Stain.
  • Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck - Best Oil-Based Deck Stain.

Is oil based stain better than latex stain?

Oil stains were traditionally the best, but now with the improved waterborne technology you can often get the same results or better with latex acrylics. An added benefit to these products is a soap and water clean up and decreased harm to your landscaping and shrubbery.

Does oil-based stain need to be sealed?

Yes, sealing wood after staining is crucial to protect the finish from moisture, dirt, and wear. Choose a compatible sealant like polyurethane, varnish, or lacquer based on the project's use and desired sheen. Apply multiple thin coats, sanding lightly between coats for a smooth finish.

Does oil based stain yellow over time?

Alkyd/oil based paints, because of their curing mechanism, tend to yellow, particularly in areas that are not exposed to sunlight. Oil-based varnishes start with an amber cast and will darken with age.

Should I sand between coats of oil based stain?

Do not let the stain dry before wiping excess. 5) A second coat can be applied after two hours. NOTE: Do not sand between coats.

How long do you leave oil stain on wood before wiping off?

Wipe the stain off immediately if you'd like a lighter tone. But for a deeper tone, leave the stain on the wood for 5 to 10 minutes before wiping it off. Be sure to wipe off all the excess stain going in the direction of the grain of the wood.

What stain is better, transparent or semi-transparent?

If you are looking to maintain the natural beauty of your wood with minimal color correction, transparent stain is likely the best option. If you want to add some color while still maintaining a natural look, semi-transparent stain is a good choice.

Is it better to oil or stain cedar?

Caveats For Using Stain on Cedar

If the Cedar has considerable shade with little to no UV exposure, using a stain instead of an oil might be appropriate. This is usually when a house is shaded by dense tree cover or has wide soffits, such as villas where the roof extends over the porch.

What are the disadvantages of oil based finishes?

Oil Based Cons
  • Longer drying times.
  • Higher levels of VOCs.
  • Higher emissions.
  • Stronger odour: requires well ventilation area during application.
  • Higher initial product costs.

Does oil-based stain need 2 coats?

If the stain looks evenly coated and you like the look, one coat staining is adequate. If the stain is too light or uneven, a second coat of stain may be needed before the topcoat is applied. Apply using a foam brush, bristle brush, paint pad applicator, or a lint-free cloth such as an old T-shirt.

What happens if you don't sand wood before staining?

Do You Have to Sand Before Staining Wood? Wood needs to be sanded well before it can be stained. The process opens up the wood's pores to better absorb the stain. It also smoothes away scratches in the surface which will only be enhanced by stain.

How long does it take oil-based stain to fully cure?

Most oil-based stains must dry for at least 12 hours before they are exposed to any moisture/rain; however, Ready Seal, if properly applied to prepped and dried wood, can get wet within a couple of hours, and it won't wash away. Oil-based stains will generally take 24-72 hours to fully cure.

What are the disadvantages of oil based stain?

Cons of Oil Stains
  • Longer Drying Time: The extended drying time can be a drawback for those seeking quicker project completion.
  • Odor and VOCs: Oil-based stains can emit strong odors and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), requiring proper ventilation.

Which stain lasts the longest?

Stain Application Frequency
  • Clear and transparent stains need a touchup every year or two.
  • Semi-transparent last 2 to 3 years.
  • Semi-solid stains are good for 2 to 4 years of protection.
  • Solid stains on decks may protect up to 5 to 7 years.

Can I put latex stain over oil stain?

If you put latex paint over oil, you'll end up with that fruit roll-up look all over your house because they just can't adhere. Since they're not compatible, they won't form a good bond.

What is the most popular deck stain color for 2024?

The Top Deck Colors for Summer 2024, According to Experts
  • 01 of 08. Muted Blue. Courtesy of Valspar. ...
  • 02 of 08. Rich Mahogany. Courtesy of Benjamin Moore. ...
  • 03 of 08. Deep Chocolate Brown. ...
  • 04 of 08. Grounding Green. ...
  • 05 of 08. Midtone Golden Brown. ...
  • 06 of 08. Deep, Sophisticated Brown. ...
  • 07 of 08. Cool Gray. ...
  • 08 of 08. Sage Green-Gray.

Is Behr or Sherwin Williams deck stain better?

Consumer Reports just tested 76 products under tough conditions that accelerate the effects of the elements, from spring showers to summer sun to the sleet and snow that can torment siding and decks in colder months. Sherwin-Williams won big among paints, while Behr took home top honors among stains.

What is the most durable finish for a deck?

Oil-Based Stains Preferred: Oil-based stains are the best choice for exotic hardwoods. These stains penetrate deeply into the dense wood, enhancing the natural grain and rich color. Oil-based stains provide a durable finish that protects the wood from UV damage and moisture while highlighting its natural beauty.

Previous article
Is 30 SECONDS as good as wet and forget?
Next article
Do old refrigerators use a lot of electricity?