Do you have to drain a water heater to change the elements?

Author: Prof. Benny Pfannerstill DDS  |  Last update: Friday, April 25, 2025

Let the water heater drain completely if you are replacing the lower element or partially if you are replacing the upper element. Sediment in the bottom of the tank may clog the drain valve and prevent it from draining properly.

Can you change a water heater element without draining it?

If this question is pertaining to a electric tank water heater - No. The tank must be fully drained and cooled before you can change the heating element. Normally there are two, a high and a low elements. If you must change one, order both.

Do you have to drain a hot water heater to change the elements?

Allow the tank to drain until the water line is below the heating element, or drain the whole tank if you're replacing the lower element. One of the pros of a tankless water heater is that it takes just a few seconds to drain the water heater. A tank water heater can take up to 15 minutes.

How long does it take to replace a hot water heater element?

It's time-consuming: Replacing a water heater element usually takes around 2–3 hours if you try and do it yourself. However, it usually only takes 1–2 hours for a professional. A professional has the right tools and skills to do the job.

What happens if you don't drain your water heater?

If you don't drain or flush your hot water heater, minerals and sediments from the water supply will settle at the bottom of the tank.

Change a hot water heater element without draining or spilling water

Is it ever too late to drain a water heater?

NOTE: If your water heater has been installed more than five years without any maintenance, it may be too late to flush. If the tank will not drain, sediment likely has built and clogged the drain.

Should I flush a 7 year old water heater?

If neither you nor a professional have flushed your water within the last five years, Water Heaters Now recommends not flushing it yourself.

How do I know if water heater element is bad?

Another common sign your water heater element is burned out is that hot water won't reach the temperature you set it to. Constant lukewarm water is a sign of electrical failure causing the heating element not to heat properly or causing sediment buildup that is impeding the heating process.

Why do I still have no hot water after changing the element?

If the unit is powered with the correct voltage, and still does not produce any hot water, the upper heating element has probably burned out. A water heater must be completely full of water before electric power is applied or the upper heating element will burn out (this is called Dry Fire).

What is the average life of a water heater element?

Your water heater's heating element should last at least as long as the water heater itself — about 10 to 15 years for an electric tank water heater and about 20 years for a tankless water heater. The only reason you would have to replace the heating element before the water heater is if there is a malfunction.

Can you replace just heating element in hot water heater?

But, a failed heating element doesn't necessarily mean you need to replace the entire water heater. In this article, we'll outline the steps for installing a new heating element and getting your water heater back up-and-running again.

Can you burn out a water heater element?

As you just found out, even a few seconds of dry firing an electric water heater can burn out your water heater element.

How do I know if my element is gone in my hot water tank?

A burned-out water heater element will often cause your water heater to produce lukewarm or cold water, even when the thermostat is set to a high temperature. You might also notice the hot water runs out faster than usual. In severe cases, you'll have no hot water at all.

Do you drain water heater to change element?

Let the water heater drain completely if you are replacing the lower element or partially if you are replacing the upper element. Sediment in the bottom of the tank may clog the drain valve and prevent it from draining properly.

How much does it cost to replace an element in a hot water heater?

Heater Element Replacements

Having a water heater element repaired professionally usually costs about $200 to $300.

Can I replace a heating element myself?

Replacing the oven element is a simple enough job if you consider yourself reasonably handy around the house, have the proper tools, and know where to buy the right part. Here's a step-by-step breakdown of replacing the oven element.

What are the symptoms of a bad thermostat on a hot water heater?

Signs Your Water Heater Thermostat Is Faulty
  • You have no hot water.
  • You're running out of hot water quickly.
  • The water is too hot.
  • It takes a long time for your water heater to heat the water.
  • You keep having to reset the high-temperature limit switch.

Why is my water heater element getting power but not heating?

No Hot Water (Power to Unit) This situation involves a water heater receiving power but not producing hot water. In this situation, if the temperature is set properly, you probably have a bad thermostat or a bad heating element.

Which element comes on first on a hot water heater?

In most cases, water heaters have two heating elements. The two heating element design allows the unit to heat water more efficiently. The bottom heating element heats up water first. The second heating element heats water at the top of the tank when it loses heat, or the demand for hot water is especially high.

What causes an electric water heater element to go bad?

A sudden voltage increase could overload a heating element of your water heater, burning it out. All elements of a water heater have voltage ratings. Voltages exceeding the rating of an element will burn it out.

Is it better to flush or drain your water heater?

It is recommended that you flush your water heater at least once per year. Doing so will help to prevent the potential problems that sediment can bring over time. Typically, it takes one to two hours to flush a water heater. The size of your tank will impact the amount of time it takes to drain.

Is a 20 year old water heater safe?

If your tank water heater is more than 10 years old, it may be time to consider replacing it. With proper maintenance, a tank water heater tank should last six to 12 years. A tankless water heater can last for more than 20 years. Check your water heater's warranty for the most accurate timelines.

Previous article
Can I use plywood instead of drywall in my garage?
Next article
Do I need a permit to build a sauna?