What am I doing wrong when sharpening a knife?

Author: Dr. Fernando Stamm  |  Last update: Tuesday, September 9, 2025

Pitfall 1: Incorrect Angles and Pressure The possibility of a razor-sharp edge vanishes when you change the angle as you progress down the blade. Find the manufacturer's suggested angle for your knife to get around this. Afterward, make sure you maintain that angle when moving the blade across the whetstone.

What is a common mistake when sharpening knives?

Using the Wrong Pressure or Angle

It's important to maintain a constant angle when sharpening and to also make sure you're applying the right amount of pressure. Too much, and you could end up with damage to your knife. Not enough, and it's not going to get sharp like you want it to.

What if there is no burr when sharpening?

No Burr Yet

A coarser grit is most often what is called for in this situation. If you have been sharpening for more then a couple of dozen strokes, and don't feel a burr indicating that you have sharpened all the way to the edge, switch to a coarser grit stone and try again.

Why is my sharpener not sharpening?

Hand-held pencil sharpeners can stop working effectively over time for several reasons: Blade Wear: The blades of the sharpener can become dull after repeated use. Dull blades struggle to sharpen pencils properly, leading to uneven tips or breakage.

How do I make my sharpener blade sharper?

Sharpen them as you would a knife blade on a whet stone or with fine grit sandpaper.

Whetstone Sharpening Mistakes that Most Beginners Make

Should you wet a knife sharpener?

Water and oil provide a lubricant on the surface to eliminate any extraneous friction, improve sharpening power, and prevent damage to the stone itself. Many chefs prefer a water stone to an oil stone – water is more convenient and facilitates a faster knife sharpening.

Should you push or pull a blade when sharpening?

Most pros would agree that pulling the blade edge across the whetstone produces the best results. Not only will it bring the knife to its sharpest but it's also a much more effective way to remove chips and imperfections from the blade.

What does a burr on a knife look like?

A burr (also called a wire edge) is a little ridge of metal that is pushed over the apex of the edge. The burr is your assurance that you've reached all the way to the apex of your bevel and will be able to create a truly sharp knife.

How to sharpen a knife that won't sharpen?

Start with the coarse grit sandpaper and move in one direction along the blade's edge. Repeat the process on the other side of the blade until the edge is sharp enough. Gradually move on to finer grit sandpaper until the knife edge is polished and razor sharp.

What is the last thing you must do when sharpening a knife?

The last step in sharpening is removing the burr – the hide side of an old leather belt will do, or buy a strop such as this one. A bit of baby oil on the leather will help you get a nice, even covering of the polishing compound. As with most things, you get what you pay for.

What should you not do when sharpening a knife?

Common mistakes include twisting, pressing down or pausing the stroke of knives as you pull them through the sharpener slot. This can cause oversharpening (the loss of too much metal) or result in an uneven edge.

Should you go back and forth when sharpening a knife?

Short answer is whatever feels comfortable and works for you. I tend to do back and forth while gradually moving up and down the blade. On my cheap utility knives, this works fine all through the grits, then I finish with edge leading on the steel.

Which knives Cannot be sharpened?

It's just some, like ceremic knives, are hard and brittle and need special equipment to sharpen them, like diamond Lapping. Ceremic blades are harder than normal honing stones, so, will not make any sharpening effort. However, pretend rubber knives are only for show and definitely cannot be sharpened.

How many strokes does it take to sharpen a dull knife?

A dull knife requires a coarse stone and may require more time using the stone. Because it can require many strokes, we suggest that you take up to 10 strokes before alternating sides.

Can you ruin a knife by sharpening it too much?

It's crucial not to sharpen your knife too frequently or apply excessive pressure, as this can cause the blade to become thin and brittle.

Why does my knife go dull so fast?

The more knives rub against other tools, the more their blades will dull. This means just opening and closing a drawer can do damage over time. Either keep your knives in individual sheaves to protect them inside the drawer, or invest in a safe storage solution like a knife block or magnetic knife strip.

What is the best knife sharpener?

Let's Cut to the Chase: The Best Knife Sharpeners
  • Shun Cutlery Combination Whetstone. ...
  • Smith's CCKS 2-Step Knife Sharpener. ...
  • AccuSharp 001C Knife Sharpener. ...
  • Work Sharp Professional Electric Culinary E5 Kitchen Knife Sharpener. ...
  • Homly Professional Electric Knife Sharpener.

How do you get rid of burr when sharpening?

Doing light sharpening on the opposite side is the way to solve this burr issue and remove them. With carbon steel knives, this is quite easy to do, but stainless steel knives are much trickier due to being more difficult to sharpen in general.

How many times do you pull a knife through a sharpener?

We recommend 6–8 pulls through the sharpener (tip up). If you need that extra degree of sharpness, polish the edge with a few strokes back and forth.

How hard should you press when sharpening a knife?

Pressure should be firm, but gentle. The blade should glide smoothly across the stone as you pull. If you need help maintaining your angle, you can use an angle guide.

Are pull through sharpeners bad for knives?

Pull-through sharpeners are the most popular way to sharpen knives, and with good reason: They are quicker than whetstones and more precise than sharpening steels. However, they shed the most amount of metal, which weakens the durability of knives.

What not to do with a sharpener?

Pushing too hard or not hard enough

You don't want to push the pencil in so little that the sharpener doesn't notice the pencil, but pushing too hard is not good for any sharpener. Applying too much force can mess with the blades and motor of the sharpener.

Do you need to wipe knife after sharpening?

It's very important that the knife blade is cleaned after sharpening and before use. There will be small, even microscopic metal particles attached to the blade that the steel has removed. Clean your blade by hand, don't let it soak in any liquids, and dry it immediately to prevent spots and rusting.

Previous article
How do you flush out a well?
Next article
Is it safe to microwave a spoon?