Is it better to replace or repair gutters?

Author: Chaz Yost  |  Last update: Thursday, August 7, 2025

Whether you should get a gutter repair or install new gutters depends on many factors. If your gutters are relatively new and the damage is minimal, a repair might be the best option. However, if your gutters are old, the damage is extensive, or they are frequently causing problems, then consider a replacement.

How often should gutters be replaced?

Gutters are an essential part of any home. They ensure water properly drains off of your roof, helping to protect the roof, siding, landscaping, and foundation from water damage. On average, gutters need to be replaced every 20 years.

How do you tell if your gutters need replacing?

Look for these five signs to determine when it's time to replace your home's gutter system:
  1. Cracks or splits of any kind. ...
  2. Paint peeling on or around your gutters and/or flecks of orange. ...
  3. Pools of water or signs of mildew around your home's foundation. ...
  4. Water damage or water marks directly beneath the gutters.

Should I replace 20 year old gutters?

How often should you replace gutters? You should replace your gutters every 20 years to ensure proper water drainage and protect your roof, siding, landscaping, and foundation. With proper care, they can last even longer.

Is it better to repair gutters or replace them?

Whether you should get a gutter repair or install new gutters depends on many factors. If your gutters are relatively new and the damage is minimal, a repair might be the best option. However, if your gutters are old, the damage is extensive, or they are frequently causing problems, then consider a replacement.

Should My Old Gutters Be Repaired or Replaced?

What type of gutters last the longest?

Pure copper gutters are considered the longest-lasting material. They can last over 50 years with proper maintenance and develop a beautiful patina over time. However, they are also significantly more expensive than other gutter materials.

Does replacing gutters increase home value?

Financial Value. Gutters do not necessarily add to the value of your home.

What happens if you don't replace gutters?

Gutters are designed to direct water away from your home, including your roof and siding. When gutters fail to do their job, water can infiltrate your roof, causing leaks, rot, and shingle damage. Water runoff can also stain and deteriorate your home's siding, necessitating expensive repairs or replacements.

Does homeowners insurance cover gutters?

If a windstorm, lightning strike, or another covered peril damages your home's gutters, your homeowners policy may pay for their repair or replacement, up to your coverage limits and minus your deductible. Your homeowners policy won't cover damage to your gutters due to negligence or wear and tear.

Do roofers install new gutters?

If they have an in-house gutter division, most roofers also offer gutter installation services with or without a roof replacement. On the other hand, companies that subcontract their work may only install gutters when replacing your roof. It really does vary, and you need to look into their specific services.

How much does it cost to repair a gutter joint?

Even for a small job, your gutter repair cost will vary depending on the issue and the repair needed. For instance, fixing a leaking gutter joint will usually cost around £60 - £90. Meanwhile, replacing a gutter support bracket will often cost just £19. A gutter repair specialist's typical day rate will be around £150.

What is the most common problem with gutters?

Problem #1: Clogged Gutters and Downspouts

Perhaps the most common gutter problem of all, clogging occurs when debris accumulates in the gutter and downspouts, blocking the flow of water and causing it to get backed up. This can result in leaks and damage to attic insulation, as well as your home's foundation.

Is replacing gutters expensive?

Gutter installation costs between $625 and $1,717, with a national average price of $1,171. Material type, home size, and labor can all affect gutter installation costs.

How often should gutters be professionally cleaned?

Many experts recommend gutters are cleaned twice a year — once at the beginning of spring and then again after the autumnal leaf drop.

What are some signs that your gutters need to be replaced?

  • Cracks. ...
  • Peeling Paint. ...
  • Pools of Water or Mildew. ...
  • Water Damage or Water Marks Directly Beneath the Gutters. ...
  • Gutters Sag or Pulling Away From the House. ...
  • Breaks at the Seams. ...
  • Rust. ...
  • Fallen Nails or Fasteners.

Why are 6 inch gutters better than 5 inch gutters?

6 Inch Gutters Hold 50% More Water Than 5 Inch Gutters

It will also protect plants below the guttering and prevent channels from forming after rainfall.

Should I replace my gutters or roof first?

Roof replacement is more extensive and may unintentionally damage your gutters. Replacing your roof first means you won't have to worry about damaging your gutters. Making sure you have a solid foundation with your roof first can provide better overall protection.

What increases house value the most?

10 quick wins for adding value before selling
  1. Redecorate. ...
  2. Fix superficial defects. ...
  3. The front door. ...
  4. Declutter. ...
  5. Heating and lighting. ...
  6. Garden appeal. ...
  7. Create a driveway / off-road parking. ...
  8. Look smart and be energy efficient.

Can bad gutters cause foundation problems?

If the clogs in your gutter system are overlooked for too long, the walls and foundation of your home can accumulate structural damage as water spills down the walls of the house, possibly pooling at its foundation.

Why replace old gutters?

One of the top reasons to replace your gutter system is to protect your house from water damage. When water doesn't flow through your gutter properly, it can leak or overflow onto other parts of your property. If it gathers around your house, it can flood into the basement and cause damage to the foundation.

What time of year should I replace my gutters?

Generally speaking, spring is the best time for gutter replacement. The winter snow has melted off the roof, but the gutters aren't clogged with debris from the fall. Having clean new gutters can also control spring rainfall, and it can add to your curb appeal when your landscaping blooms.

Which is better seamless gutters or regular gutters?

Seamless gutters are generally more durable due to the lack of joints that can weaken over time. Each section of a seamless gutter is a continuous piece of material, which means there are fewer opportunities for leaks and structural weaknesses.

What is the least maintenance guttering?

Maintenance considerations are vital when choosing your gutter material. Aluminum gutters offer a low-maintenance solution, as they do not require painting and are rust-resistant. Copper and zinc gutters also demand minimal upkeep, gradually developing a patina that protects the metal from corrosion.

Previous article
Where is the air filter on a package unit?
Next article
How long does an oven deep clean take?