Whether an agitator is "better" depends entirely on your laundry habits. An agitator is ideal if you frequently wash heavily soiled clothes and need fast cycles, while a non-agitator (impeller) washer is better for large, bulky items and gentle fabric care.
Impellers allow for more space in the wash basket, which means clothes can move more freely, helping to reduce wear and tear. The design also makes it convenient for loading and unloading bulky items. Impeller washers also typically use less water and energy than agitator models.
For the least amount of mechanical issues, Speed Queen is universally praised as the most reliable brand due to its heavy-duty, commercial-grade build. For modern, feature-rich machines, LG consistently ranks at the top for front-load reliability, and Whirlpool/GE are top choices for traditional top-loaders.
Then check our washing machine ratings for details on over 120 agitator top-loaders, HE top-loaders, front-loaders, and compact machines.
A washing machine with an impeller uses less motion and water than a washer with an agitator. Designed so laundry has more room to move, it drives clothes from the outer rim of the wash basket to the center, using a small amount of water to optimize the friction. This is what helps deliver a gentle, yet thorough clean.
Yes, you can wash a comforter in a top-load machine with a center agitator, provided the comforter fits loosely in the tub with enough room to move. If the comforter is packed tightly, it won't get clean and can get damaged.
The best washing machines without an agitator (often called impeller models) are gentler on fabrics and offer larger wash capacities. Top picks include the LG 5.0 cu. ft. Mega Capacity Smart Top Load Washer for outstanding cleaning, and the GE Profile 5.0 cu. ft. Smart Top-Load Washer for smart-home integration and tangle prevention.
Removing an agitator opens up space in the wash tub. As a result, it is easier to clean bulkier items like comforters. In addition, you can fit more clothes in the machine and get laundry done faster.
Neither system is universally better; the choice depends on your cleaning priorities. Agitators clean faster and are superior for heavily soiled, large loads, while impellers offer gentler, more water-efficient cleaning that is better for delicate items and provides more space for bulky items.
For a homemade option, you can try cleaning your washing machine with vinegar. Just pour two cups of distilled vinegar into your detergent drawer. You can also use soda crystals (or baking soda) to clean your washing machine. Sprinkle half a cup into your drum and then let your washing machine run on a hot setting.
The Electrolux 700 Series ELFW7737AT front-load washer is widely considered the top overall machine available. It earns the number one spot in industry and expert evaluations due to its class-leading energy efficiency, exceptional stain-removal capabilities, spacious capacity, and a highly accurate cycle countdown timer.
The best washing machines combine large capacity, high cleaning efficiency, and strong reliability. Top front-load picks include the LG TurboWash 360 WM4000HBA and Samsung 5.0 Cu. Ft. smart models. For top-load preferences, the Whirlpool 2-in-1 Removable Agitator and Speed Queen TC5 stand out for versatility and durability.
Choosing between GE and LG washers depends on your specific laundry needs. Generally, LG is better for front-load machines, fabric care, and advanced tech, while GE excels in smart connectivity, bulky item handling, and top-load performance.
For the least amount of mechanical issues, Speed Queen is universally praised as the most reliable brand due to its heavy-duty, commercial-grade build. For modern, feature-rich machines, LG consistently ranks at the top for front-load reliability, and Whirlpool/GE are top choices for traditional top-loaders.
Yes, agitators can ruin clothes. Because they operate by twisting back and forth and forcing clothes to rub against each other and the center post, they increase friction and wear, which can cause pilling, tearing, and snagging—especially on delicate, loosely woven, or heavily decorated garments.
A washing machine without an agitator uses a low-profile plate at the bottom of the tub, called an impeller or pulsator, to move the clothes. Instead of relying on a center post to beat and rub the laundry, it circulates the water and forces clothes to gently rub against one another to remove dirt.
Whether an agitator is "better" depends entirely on your laundry habits. An agitator is ideal if you frequently wash heavily soiled clothes and need fast cycles, while a non-agitator (impeller) washer is better for large, bulky items and gentle fabric care.
The most reliable top load washers are led by Speed Queen for commercial-grade longevity, and LG for the best balance of modern technology and low service rates.
On the short end, the washers to avoid will last around seven years (or less) and are prone to repairs during that time. On the high end, reliable washing machines can last more than 15 years, well beyond their expected timelines.
Two Wash Styles in One Machine: This is the biggest advantage. With a top load washer with removable agitator, you can switch between an agitator wash for heavy-duty cleaning and an impeller-style wash for gentler care. It's like having two machines without taking up extra space.
For a 7-year-old washing machine, a repair is usually worth it if the repair cost is less than half the price of a new machine and your washer is generally in good shape. However, if the fix involves a major component like the motor or tub bearing, replacing it is often the more cost-effective choice.
Neither washer type is strictly "better," as the choice depends on whether you prioritize heavy-duty cleaning (agitator) or efficiency and capacity (impeller). Agitator washers (central post) excel at removing tough stains and offer faster, traditional cycles. Impeller washers (low-profile disc) are gentler on clothes, use less water, and provide more space for bulky items.
Top 10 Washing Machine Companies and Brands 2026
Of the 100-plus washers tested, the $1,200 Kenmore Elite 4157[2] front-loader was the quietest. It came very close to making the recommended list and was superb at cleaning in our tests, has a large capacity, and vibration wasn't a problem.
When comparing LG vs. Whirlpool top-load washers, LG is the top choice if you want maximum features, better energy efficiency, and whisper-quiet operation. Whirlpool is generally better if you prefer reliable, traditional, and straightforward machines that are less expensive to repair.