How do you know when it's time to get a new toilet?

Author: Miss Melissa Simonis  |  Last update: Sunday, September 7, 2025

If you think that it might be time for you to replace your toilet, here are the warning signs that you should keep an eye out for.
  • Consistently Clogging. ...
  • The Bowl or Tank Are Cracked. ...
  • You've Noticed a Spike in Your Water Bill. ...
  • The Toilet Moves When You Sit on It. ...
  • It Needs Too Many Repairs. ...
  • Visual Scratches. ...
  • Faulty Flushing.

What are the signs that you need a new toilet?

8 Signs Your Toilet Needs to Be Replaced
  • Constant Clogging. Nobody likes to deal with a clogged toilet. ...
  • Cracks. When you notice puddles of water around your toilet, you may want to check for cracks in the porcelain. ...
  • Plentiful Repairs. ...
  • Excessive Age. ...
  • Wobbling. ...
  • Inefficient Flushing. ...
  • Surface Damages. ...
  • Built-Up Mineral Deposits.

What is the average life expectancy of a toilet?

One of the most used fixtures in your home, the toilet, on average has a lifespan of 10-15 years. For being used as often as it is, the toilet can withstand a lot. Unfortunately, there will come a time when you need to replace your toilet.

How do you know if your toilet is going bad?

If you frequently see a puddle of water around your toilet, this could indicate that you have cracks in your tank. Even if the toilet appears to be working properly - flushing well, not clogged, not running - but there is water around the bottom, it could mean there are cracks in the bowl.

How long does a toilet last before replacing?

Most plumbers agree that an average toilet can last around 50 years. However, this is only when the toilet is well maintained and gently used. If it was improperly installed or frequently misused, it may not last as long.

When Should You Replace Your Toilet? | 6 Signs It May Be Time For a Toilet Replacement

Should you caulk around a toilet?

Reasons to Caulk Around a Toilet

Moisture Prevention: Without caulk around the toilet base, external water can seep under the toilet, leading to floor and subfloor damage over time. This is especially important in bathrooms with wooden floors, as prolonged exposure to moisture can lead to rot and structural issues.

Should I call a plumber to replace a toilet?

A licensed plumber will ensure your new toilet is properly hooked up and the plumbing lines are in good shape. A plumber can also perform any major repairs, such as drainpipe replacement. If the floor or wall sustains any damage during the installation, you'll want to bring in a flooring and drywall contractor.

How do you test a toilet?

Put 10-15 drops of food coloring or a dye tablet in the toilet tank. Wait 30 minutes without flushing. After 30 minutes, if the water in the bowl turns color, your toilet tank is leaking. Replace the parts inside your toilet tank.

Why does my toilet flush but poop stays after flushing?

It is quite common for minerals such as calcium and lime, along with debris particles such as rust to build up in the rim feed and jet holes of the toilet bowl. Over time, these deposits restrict and block water from flowing into the toilet bowl which will cause a weak or incomplete flush.

Can you replace an old toilet with any new toilet?

It boils down to something much simpler — size. That's right, not every toilet fits in every bathroom. You need to make sure to measure your existing toilet accurately to ensure that the new one will fit in its place. Here's how to ensure your replacement toilet will fit in your bathroom.

How long do toilet wax rings last?

The wax ring is exactly what it sounds like: a ring made of sticky wax that helps form a watertight seal between the bottom of the toilet and the sewer pipe. It requires no maintenance and can last 30 or more years, often as long as the toilet itself. But sometimes wax rings can dry out, crumble, and fail prematurely.

How often do toilets need maintenance?

Check this valve at least once a month to ensure it always works properly. Maintenance checks. Last but not least, regular maintenance must be scheduled for the well-being of the toilet. Even with these toilet maintenance tips, homeowners still need a professional to examine their toilet once a year.

Is it cheaper to fix a toilet or replace it?

Some problems require expensive, complicated repairs. If you encounter these issues frequently, scheduling a replacement will most likely be the most cost-effective solution, as you can save money.

How do I know what new toilet to buy?

For one or two people with limited space, a dual flush, one-piece or wall-mounted toilet is a great choice. They will save you water plus you can often add pampering choices like heated toilet seats. For a family or a group of three or more, choose a two-piece toilet with a pressure-assisted or power-flushing feature.

Do newer toilets flush better?

When the federal government mandated that new toilets use no more than 1.6 gallons per flush, manufacturers had to develop a toilet that would achieve this but that would also flush properly (clear the bowl) and carry the waste to the city sewer or septic system. Some of the early models did not do this properly.

How do you know if a toilet is bad?

If you experience clogs more than once a week or instances that seem random, it may be time to retire the commode. If you have an older low-flush toilet, this may be the problem. Older generation low-flush toilets are notorious for random stoppages and require more than one flush most of the time.

How to tell if a toilet wax ring needs replacing?

The first sign of a bad toilet ring is water forming around the base of the toilet. To test that a bad seal is the problem, grab a couple of towels and wipe up the water. Go on with your day, checking periodically to see if the water has returned.

How much should a plumber charge to replace a toilet?

Replacing a toilet costs between $275 and $480 in most cases, and the average cost sits around $375.

What do plumbers say is the best toilet?

Brands that Plumbers Suggest in 2024

Toto: A Japanese brand that is often praised for its advanced flushing technology and water-saving features. TOTO toilets are known for their efficiency and durability. American Standard: This brand is recognized for its quality and variety.

Is replacing a toilet a big job?

Complex Installation: Replacing a toilet involves more than just physical labor. It requires knowledge of plumbing systems, the ability to ensure a proper seal with the floor flange, and the skill to connect the water supply without leaks.

Is it better to put wax ring on toilet or flange?

Position the new toilet wax ring on top of the toilet flange, ensuring it is centered. Want to know more about choosing the correct wax ring size, crucial installation tips, and other frequently asked questions?

How often should you Recaulk a toilet?

Signs It's Time to Recaulk Your Bathroom
  1. Mold or mildew beneath the surface of the caulk, indicating water leakage.
  2. Caulk is older than five years.
  3. Dried out or cracked caulk.
  4. Peeling or missing caulk.

How to fix a gap between a toilet and a wall?

Toilet tank braces can be adjusted to fit the gap between your tank and wall. Clipped on back edge of tank, under lid, braces are practically invisible when installed. Anchor your tanks with Secure-A-Tank to protect against costly leaks and repairs.

Previous article
Why is it so hard to let go of clutter?
Next article
What causes an electric water heater element to go bad?