How can you tell if a cast iron skillet is good?

Author: Penelope Ratke  |  Last update: Monday, September 1, 2025

To determine the condition of a used cast-iron skillet before purchasing, inspect for rust, cracks, and pitting. Check the cooking surface for smoothness. Rust can be reconditioned, but extensive damage may be irreversible.

How to know if a cast iron skillet is good?

  • Look for a smooth and shiny surface: A well-seasoned cast iron pan should have a smooth and shiny surface.
  • Check for a dark color: Cast iron that has been seasoned properly will develop a dark color, often black or deep brown.
  • Check for a non-stick surface: A well-seasoned cast iron pan should have a non-stick surface.

When should I throw away my cast iron skillet?

This Is When to Throw Away a Cast Iron Skillet
  1. Dealbreaker 1: A Wobbly Base. Warping can happen to all cookware, even cast iron; typically as a result of very high heat or temperature fluctuations. ...
  2. Dealbreaker 2: A Crack. ...
  3. Dealbreaker 3: A Hole. ...
  4. Probably Not a Dealbreaker: Rust.

What is the life expectancy of a cast iron skillet?

With proper care cast iron cookware can withstand a lifetime of use. Actually several lifetimes as these cast iron pans and dutch ovens are often passed down from generation to generation. Taking care of cast iron cookware is as easy as 1 – 2 – 3.

How long should a cast iron skillet last?

Don't let that scare you off—a cast iron skillet can last a lifetime (or longer!) and is easy to maintain if you remember a few simple cleaning tips. If you ever mess it up, don't worry: The great thing about cast iron is that it's easy to restore.

How To Tell If Cast Iron Is Seasoned Or Not

How can you tell if a cast iron pan is very old?

Robert says a quick way to determine if the pan is early or pre-20th century is to look for a gate mark on the bottom side. “A gate mark looks like a slash and was a by-product of older iron casting methods,” he explains.

Do you wash cast iron after every use?

You should season a cast-iron skillet at least once a month, but seasoning it after each time you cook with it also works. You may not need to repeat the entire seasoning process as you did before initially using it, but after each use, rinse it and give your cast-iron skillet a quick season by oiling it.

Do cast iron skillets get better with age?

Cast-iron skillets are the workhorses of any good cookware set. They develop a natural nonstick coating when properly maintained that just improves over time.

Can you bring a cast iron skillet back to life?

A cast iron skillet can almost always be brought back to life and its age is often seen as pro rather than a con. That's why thrift stores and estate sales are great places to find cast iron skillets inexpensively.

Which cast iron brand is best?

Our Top Picks
  • Best Overall: Lodge Blacklock Cast Iron Skillet at Amazon $60. ...
  • Best Budget: SALE. ...
  • Best Enameled: Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Skillet at Amazon $220. ...
  • Best Splurge: Stargazer Cast Iron Skillet at Amazon $135. ...
  • Best Set: Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron 5-Piece Set at Amazon $100. ...
  • Most Versatile: ...
  • Best Grill Pan:

Will a magnet stick to a cast iron skillet?

Yes, cast iron exhibits magnetic properties. Iron is inherently magnetic due to the alignment of its electrons. To understand magnetism, it's important to understand the structure of a material.

Should cast iron be shiny or dull?

Some cast-iron skillets, including those made by Lodge, come pre-seasoned. You'll notice they have a smooth, non-greasy, softly lacquered surface. Those that don't come pre-seasonsed have a matte gray finish—until you season them, at which point they become shiny and closer to black in color.

How to spot a fake cast iron skillet?

How can you tell if a pan is cast iron or a fake?
  1. Feel the weight. Pick up the pan and feel the weight. ...
  2. Check the bottom of the pan. There should be a manufacturer logo marked on the pan, often with the stock number or city it was manufactured in.
  3. Check for rust. ...
  4. Check the handle. ...
  5. Check the pan's surface.

When not to use a cast iron skillet?

What Not to Cook in a Cast-Iron Skillet
  • Avoid Cooking Acidic Foods in Cast-Iron Pans. ...
  • Be Aware that a Cast-Iron Surface Takes on Flavors. ...
  • Don't Cook Delicate Fish In Cast Iron. ...
  • Before Your Skillet Is Well-Seasoned, Avoid Sticky Foods. ...
  • And, Whatever You Cook, Avoid Storing Food in Your Cast-Iron Pan.

What does a healthy cast iron skillet look like?

A well-seasoned cast iron pan should be dark black, shiny, and smooth to the touch. Unseasoned cast iron has a rough look and feel until it is properly seasoned. Here are some sure signs of damage and misuse: It's covered in rust.

What ruins a cast iron skillet?

You let your skillet soak.

Soaking your cast iron skillet in your sink is a recipe for rust, as is washing it in the dishwasher. Instead, clean it ASAP, even using simple soap and water if you must.

How do I know if my cast iron pan is good?

Features to Look for in Cast Iron Cookware
  1. Handles: Check on the cookware's handles. ...
  2. Thickness and weight: In general, with cast iron, the thicker and heavier it is, the better. ...
  3. Quality of enamel coating: If you're buying a cast iron pan that's enameled, make sure that the enamel is high quality.

What is the lifespan of a cast iron pan?

Keep It Seasoned

Seasoning cast iron is an easy process which makes it different from other pans. You season it once and it's good for decades.

Is a little rust on cast iron ok?

Cooking with a cast iron pan that has a little bit of surface rust on it isn't likely to hurt you. If your pan is seriously rusty or has visible rust flakes, you shouldn't cook with it until the rust is removed and the pan is washed and re-seasoned.

What's the best oil to season cast iron?

Common cooking oils like olive oil will gradually produce seasoning, but won't be as effective as grapeseed oil. Canola, other vegetable oils, and shortening are a little better.

Can you use a cast iron skillet on a glass top stove?

Cast iron cookware can be used on a ceramic glass-top stove without causing damage to the surface or pan itself. Take the stress out of dinner with the ability to cook a variety of different meals in a cast iron pan without damaging your cooktop.

How can you tell if cast iron is bad?

When Should You Throw Away Your Cast Iron Pan?
  1. Cracks. Many cast iron pans develop cracks over time, especially when used frequently at high temperatures. ...
  2. Chips and Holes. Your cast iron pan could start chipping for various reasons. ...
  3. Warping. Another sign of cast iron damage is warping.

What does the number 8 mean on cast iron?

Field sizing is based on vintage cast iron conventions, so our No. 8 size means a 10 ¼" width, edge-to-edge. Dimensions: 10 ¼" diameter.

What is the oldest cast iron brand?

Lodge Cast Iron is the oldest and longest-running cast iron manufacturer in the United States. Originally called Blacklock, founder Joseph Lodge fired up a long-dormant railroad foundry in South Pittsburg, Tennessee in 1896.

Previous article
How to ventilate a windowless bathroom?
Next article
Which side of drywall is mold-resistant?