You can safely do both, but the direction determines the result. Pushing (edge-leading) removes material faster to establish the edge but risks gouging the stone. Pulling (edge-trailing) refines the edge and creates a polished finish.
In knife sharpening, "push" (edge-leading) means the blade's edge moves into the abrasive, while "pull" (edge-trailing) means the spine leads. Use push strokes to efficiently set your edge angle and remove metal, and pull strokes for finishing, refining the apex, and safely removing the burr.
Sharpening a knife effectively relies on maintaining a consistent angle (usually 15 to 20 degrees), applying steady pressure (about 2-4 lbs), and establishing a wire edge or "burr". The most precise way to restore a razor-sharp, custom edge is by using a flat whetstone.
There's a hundred different ways to sharpen a knife. In general though the small back and forth motions are referred to as sharpening in sections. It's what I do to form the bevel and refine the edge typically when I'm on stones from 120 to 2k in grit.
Pull-through sharpeners are not universally "bad," but they are generally discouraged for high-quality or expensive knives. They offer quick, convenient edge maintenance but are highly aggressive, removing excess metal and often leaving a fragile, jagged edge.
Here are the most common mistakes and proven ways to avoid them:
Cutting boards made of glass, granite, ceramic, or your dinner plate may look stylish or convenient, but they are the fastest way to destroy a knife's edge. These surfaces are harder than your knife's steel. So every time your blade contacts them, it suffers microscopic edge deformation, chipping, or even rolling.
Don't run your knife through a knife system or device. Running your blade through a device will unevenly chew up the edge, can scratch the face of the blade, and will not get your knife as sharp as using a whetstone to sharpen. Do not belt sharpen knives.
Rule #1: It is important to use a knife adapted to what you want to do / food you want to prepare. For example, you shouldn't use a bread knife to slice a roast or use the blade of a paring knife and use it as a screwdriver (don't laugh, we've all done it!) Rule #2: Don't drop your knife on the floor.
Yes, you can use WD-40 as a lubricant on oil-based sharpening stones, but it is not the best option. Because WD-40 is very thin, it fails to effectively float away metal shavings (swarf), which can clog your stone.
If your knife is very dull or has a nicked blade, start with your coarsest stone. The coarse stone removes material quickly so a poor edge can be refined quickly. However, the coarse stone must be followed up with your finer stone to refine the edge.
The more you sharpen a knife, the sharper it will get
This is not true. Over-sharpening a knife can actually damage the edge and make it duller.
No, aluminum foil cannot truly sharpen a knife. Aluminum is much softer than steel, so it lacks the abrasive material needed to shave off metal and reshape the edge.
The blade edge should face in the same direction as your stroke. So, you're essentially moving the metal away from the edge. We recommend the circular stroke as it helps you maintain your angle instead of having to find it every time you lift the knife from the stone.
Choosing the Best Grit for Sharpening Knives
For most home cooks, a 1000-grit stone is the best option to get started. Follow up with a 4000 or 6000 grit stone to polish the edge. An 8000 grit is very effective for those who want an exceptionally refined mirror finish.
In the high-end folding knife community, the original "Holy Trinity" refers to three legendary American makers who pioneered the modern premium tactical folder. Together, their designs set the gold standard for durability and precision.
Never soak knives with wooden handles in water; prolonged exposure can damage the handle and rivets. Knives with plastic handles and without rivets can be soaked for longer periods without issue.
In most places, including across the U.S., it is not illegal to carry a standard, non-locking Swiss Army Knife. Because they generally have small blades (under 3 inches) and require two hands to open, they are classified as legal pocket knives rather than prohibited weapons.
You should hone before every use, and sharpen with a whetstone 2-3 times a year, if you're a normal amateur chef. And I just wipe down my knives with a dishtowel after honing, and with a quick rinse with some dishsoap and water after sharpening. You shouldn't need to sharpen with a whetstone before every single use.
For whetstone sharpening, you should generally sharpen your knives wet. Using water or honing oil provides crucial lubrication that carries away metal shavings, prevents the stone from clogging, and acts as a coolant to protect the steel's temper from heat.
It's all about angle. Sharpening is nothing more than grinding a V or angle on the edge of a blade. Holding a consistent angle throughout the sharpening process is what's important. A good rule of thumb is to visualize placing a matchbook on the steel or stone as an angle guide.
Navy SEALs do not have a single standard-issue knife, but rather carry a mix of specific duty blades, hard-use survival tools, and custom-chosen personal knives.
Ceramic knives retain their sharpness the longest. Made from zirconium oxide, they stay sharp up to ten times longer than steel, but are brittle and can easily chip if dropped or used on hard items. For a durable blade with incredible edge retention, high-carbon Japanese steel (like SG2 or ZDP-189) is the premier choice.