Can a thermostat be bad and not overheat?

Author: Mr. Roel Rutherford MD  |  Last update: Tuesday, April 29, 2025

One of the lesser-known issues is the polar opposite of overheating. Overcooling happens when the engine does not reach the right temperature for its normal function. In this scenario, the thermostat is stuck open and overflows the radiator with coolant, drastically reducing the engine life cycle.

Can a thermostat be bad without overheating?

Technically, a faulty thermostat will not break anything. But it can lead to overheating of the engine, and that can definitely cause damage. If the engine begins to overheat, there should be indicators such as a temperature gauge and/or a warning light to notify the driver.

What are the symptoms of a bad thermostat?

What Are the Signs of a Bad or Broken Thermostat?
  • The AC or Furnace Won't Come On. ...
  • The HVAC System Won't Turn Off. ...
  • The Thermostat Is Unresponsive. ...
  • The HVAC System Short-Cycles. ...
  • The Room Temperature Doesn't Match the Thermostat Setting. ...
  • The Programmed Settings Reset Themselves. ...
  • Check and Adjust the Settings.

Can a bad thermostat cause the fan to stay on?

A bad thermostat can also cause the fan to run continuously or not turn off when it should. To ensure your thermostat is functioning correctly, it is recommended to consult with HVAC Alliance Expert's specialists.

Will a bad thermostat run a code?

Yes, a faulty thermostat can trigger the check engine light in your vehicle. The thermostat regulates the engine's temperature by controlling the flow of coolant. If it fails to open or close properly, it can lead to overheating or underheating of the engine.

When You Do And Do Not Need A Thermostat

How can I tell if I need to replace my thermostat?

Signs You Need a New Thermostat
  1. Heating or cooling system will not turn off or on.
  2. The temperature reading is incorrect.
  3. Recent spike in your energy bill.
  4. Frequent temperature fluctuations.
  5. Thermostat is 10 years old or older.

Will a stuck thermostat throw a code?

A stuck thermostat will also trigger several indicators, warnings, and fault codes. As you read above, you'll first notice the blue low-temperature indicator that constantly stays on.

What are the symptoms of a faulty temperature sensor?

What Are The Symptoms of a Faulty Temperature Sensor?
  • The equipment is experiencing intermittent thermocouple failure.
  • Instruments are showing “Open Circuit”.
  • The temperature gauge on your equipment isn't reading accurately.
  • The equipment stops heating or cooling properly.
  • The equipment is overheating.

How to check a thermostat?

Methods for Testing Your Thermostat
  1. Just Turn it On and Let it Work. One way to test your thermostat is to simply turn it on and see if it cools the room down. ...
  2. Get an Indoor Thermometer. Another way to test your thermostat is to use a thermometer. ...
  3. Use a Multimeter. ...
  4. What to Do if You Notice an Issue.

Why is my fan running when my thermostat is off?

Your Furnace Fan Limit Switch Is Set to Manual

When the thermostat turns off—and no heat is necessary—the switch should turn off. However, if the switch is set to manual, the blower won't turn off. Check to see if your furnace's fan limit switch is set to manual.

Can a bad thermostat cause AC not to cool?

When your thermostat is working correctly, you can keep it as cool or warm as you need. A bad thermostat can cause your AC to not cool or heat the room to the desired temperature. Air conditioning concerns are more apparent: Your thermostat is one of the best indicators of your air conditioning system's health.

What are the symptoms of a bad head gasket?

Common Signs of a Bad Head Gasket
  • Coolant Loss: Keep an eye on your coolant levels — a significant drop is a red flag. ...
  • White Smoke from the Tailpipe: Some white smoke from the exhaust pipe of a cold engine is normal. ...
  • Engine Knocking: Blown head gaskets can lead to poor compression. ...
  • Milky Oil: Check your engine's oil.

How do I know if my water pump or thermostat is bad?

Here are signs you've got a bad pump or thermostat.
  1. Corroded Cooling System Parts. Both of these cooling system parts can get corroded if they start to leak slowly. ...
  2. Leaking Engine Coolant. ...
  3. Erratic Temperature Changes. ...
  4. Poor Coolant Circulation. ...
  5. Overheating Constantly.

How to diagnose a bad thermostat?

Temperature Fluctuations: One of the most common signs of a bad thermostat is erratic temperature readings on your dashboard gauge. If you notice that the temperature gauge moves from normal to hot quickly or fluctuates unexpectedly, it's a clear indication that your thermostat may be malfunctioning.

How much does it cost to replace a thermostat?

The average cost of a new thermostat, including installation, ranges in price from $50 to $500 or more based on several factors including the type of thermostat, labor costs, the complexity of the installation, and more.

Why is my thermostat on but not cooling?

There are a number of reasons why your air conditioner might be running but not cooling. It could be an issue with the thermostat, the compressor, or the evaporator coils. Or, it could simply be clogged with dust and debris, which is preventing it from working properly.

Will a car run with a bad coolant temperature sensor?

If your coolant temperature sensor is failing or has failed, do not continue driving your vehicle. You should get it fixed right away. A faulty sensor can lead to overheating. This will cause damage to your engine as well as other components, which will be very expensive to fix.

How do you test if a temperature sensor is working?

To test a temperature sensor with a multimeter, set it to measure resistance, clip one probe to an outer sensor connector and the other across from it. Submerge in hot then ice water, note readings after a few seconds - around 250 and 1000 ohms respectively.

What happens if I unplug the coolant temperature sensor?

It's not recommended to unplug the coolant temperature sensor unless necessary for diagnostic purposes, as it can adversely affect engine operation and potentially cause damage if left unplugged for an extended period.

How do I know if my car needs a new thermostat?

5 Signs Your Thermostat Is Broken
  1. You Notice Erratic Temperature Changes. ...
  2. You Find Incorrect Readings on the Temperature Gauge. ...
  3. Your Vehicle Makes Concerning Noises. ...
  4. You Find Coolant Leaks. ...
  5. You Notice Problems with the Heating System.

Will a bad thermostat cause no heat?

Often, no heat in the home is a result of thermostat issues, whether they be true malfunctions or errors in settings. Whenever you notice no heat, check your thermostat first for troubleshooting. Make sure your thermostat is on – the display should be on as normal. If it's not, there could be a power issue.

What happens when a thermostat sensor goes bad?

While sometimes a faulty sensor sends a permanent cold signal to the engine, it can also send a permanent hot signal. The computer will again miscalculate the signal and cause the engine to heat up instead of cooling it down. When this happens, the car might misfire, or it could lead to engine knocking.

Previous article
What are the symptoms of quick wilt?
Next article
What heat pump has the best warranty?