Which is better water or soil propagation?

Author: Weston Deckow V  |  Last update: Monday, March 31, 2025

And yes, there are also other ways to propagate, but water propagation is the simplest way to start if you're new to propagating plants, or simply want to speed up the process, as cuttings root faster in water vs soil, plus you can easily see what's going on each step of the way.

Is it better to propagate in soil or water?

Always propagate in dry soil. Water propping gets you WATER roots (which die after you transplant to soil- leaving you back to square 1). No wet soil or it will rot the stem and prevent roots. They are triggered by drought so they will sprout roots in search of water if your soil is dry.

Do roots grow faster in water or soil?

Soil roots need more energy to grow, which is why cuttings grow roots faster in water vs soil. Soil roots are tougher and thicker.

Do plants grow better in water or soil?

There are plenty of advantages to growing hydroponically over soil-based gardening. Among them include the ability to grow more plants in a smaller space, fewer pests to worry about and no weeding. Another advantage is that many plants grow faster when raised hydroponically.

What is the best propagation method?

Stem Cuttings:

This technique is probably the most versatile of all methods used for vegetative propagation. It can be used for both herbaceous and woody material.

Water vs Soil Propagation: 7 Week Comparison with Pothos | Should I propagate in water or soil?

How long can propagated plants stay in water?

As long as you give them proper nutrients in the water, they can thrive indefinitely without soil.

What is the cheapest way of propagation?

Propagating by saving and sowing seed

Growing plants from seed is one of the cheapest and most effective ways of propagating plants.

Why is water better than soil?

Plants growing in water maximize the spaces they are in and are perfect for people with limited spaces or no gardens. Since the plant roots don't have to spread far in the soil for nutrients and moisture, the plant is able to grow in a smaller space.

How do I make my own rooting hormone?

All you need to make a rooting powder with apple cider vinegar is the vinegar itself and water. You only need to add one teaspoon to each 1.2 to 1.4 litres of water. This should give the plants a slight boost to help them root successfully.

Is it better to propagate pothos in water or soil?

All types of pothos can be propagated in either soil or water. Water propagation is usually faster, while soil propagation produces sturdier plant roots and cuttings that may not need to be transplanted later if you propagate them in a roomy pot.

What is the best substrate for propagation?

Perlite gives best results if mixed with an equal volume of peat moss or vermiculite. Compressed peat pellets that expand when water is added make a convenient propagation medium and container. Heavy soils should not be used for rooting.

Can you propagate all plants in soil?

Propagation for many plants is best done in potting soil, but some plants can be propagated in water. This is because they have evolved in an environment that allows it. Most Aroid plants can be propagated in water, including pothos plants, philodendrons, monsteras, and ZZ plants.

How often should I change the water for plants growing in water?

Change the water at least twice a week to keep it clean and oxygenated. Roots will generally appear within 3-4 weeks. When the roots are an inch or two (2.5 or 5 cm) long, remove the cutting from the water and plant it in a well-draining planting medium.

Do roots grow better in water or soil?

Water roots grow much faster than soil roots and require less space and energy to grow. They are designed to absorb nutrients from the water all around them, so they don't have to grow as large to search for resources. Soil roots, on the other hand, are much sturdier and have fewer thin offshoots than water roots.

What is the best natural rooting hormone?

Willow trees are rich in natural auxin hormone, which helps spur new roots faster. Willows are the most potent in the spring when the trees begin to leaf out, but you can make this mixture any time. If you're making willow tea in the spring, use only the stems from new growth.

Should I put fertilizer in water when propagating?

While fertilizer isn't necessary in the early stages, adding it later can boost growth for long-term water propagation. Using a highly diluted solution ensures that the new roots get the nutrients they need without the risk of over-fertilization.

Can I use cinnamon instead of rooting hormone?

Embarking on your quest to propagate plants, you might wonder, "What can I use instead of rooting hormone?" Cinnamon emerges as a stellar candidate due to its natural antifungal properties. These properties help safeguard your delicate cuttings against common fungal threats that often compromise root development.

Is Epsom salt a rooting hormone?

Epsom salt promotes deep root growth for plants so during times of drought or little rainfall, Epsom salt plants will have deep roots to seek out moisture and nutrients. Plants with deep roots thrive when other plants with shallow roots shrivel up and die if water is not constantly provide to them.

Does vinegar work as a rooting hormone?

Using apple cider vinegar as a rooting hormone is a safe and natural way to weaken the outer coating of seeds, making for faster germination.

What plants can live in water forever?

Plants That Grow in Water without Soil
  • Pothos. Pothos is one of the most popular choices for water growth. ...
  • Lucky Bamboo. This plant is almost exclusively sold in water-only containers and held in place by a layer of pebbles or decorative stones. ...
  • Spider Plant. ...
  • English Ivy. ...
  • Chinese Evergreen. ...
  • Coleus. ...
  • Philodendron. ...
  • Begonia.

What liquids help plants grow best?

After weeks of giving each plant different liquids(water, carbonated water, mango juice and pineapple soda), the conclusion is carbonated water grows plants the fastest and the healthiest.

What will happen if you put too much water in your plant?

Plants growing in soil that is too wet suffer from a lack of oxygen which leads to the death of roots and a loss of vigor in the plant. Stunted slow growth with yellowing leaves is a symptom of over-watering.

Why is propagation illegal?

In the case of prosecuting patent infringement, proper identification of the new plant with the cultivar name and patent number presumes such knowledge. Propagation of a patented plant for any purpose without permission from the patent owner is illegal and an infringement of the plant patent owner's rights.

What is the fastest plant to propagate?

Easy Houseplants to Propagate
  • Pothos (Epipremnum aureum)
  • Sansevieria, Snake Plant (Dracaena trifasciata syn: Sansevieria trifasciata)
  • Spider Plant (Chlorophytum comosum)
  • Zz Plant (Zamioculcas zamiifolia)
  • Chinese Money Plant (Pilea peperiomoides)
  • Tradescantia, Inch plant (Tradescantia spp.)

Is propagating in soil or water better?

Propagating plants from cuttings is one of the easiest and most used methods of propagation. Many plants will root from just a section of a plant. Some plants will root in water, but cuttings will develop a better root system when rooted in a soil-less potting mix.

Previous article
How can I test my water pressure?
Next article
Do alcohol wipes clean screens?