When comparing vinyl and aluminum downspouts, aluminum is the superior and more popular choice for overall durability. Vinyl is cheaper and easier to install yourself, but aluminum withstands severe weather and extreme temperature fluctuations much better without cracking or warping.
Common materials used in downspout drainage
Downspouts are generally constructed from aluminum or galvanized steel. The former is cheap, light, and durable, but the former offers additional strength. Copper is popular for its beautiful patina and longevity, but it comes at a premium price.
The life expectancy of aluminum and galvanized gutters is 20+ years, according to the International Association of Certified Home Inspectors, while vinyl gutters and downspouts can last for 25 years in mild climates.
The Cons of Aluminum Gutters
Whereas copper gutters regularly last for over 50 years, aluminum gutters tend to give in within 30 years. This is because they're much more prone to rusting. In addition, aluminum gutters don't tend to have that "high-end" aesthetic that copper gutters have.
To handle heavy rain, the best system is a 6-inch or 7-inch seamless K-style gutter made of heavy-gauge aluminum. Seamless designs prevent leaks at the joints, while K-style gutters hold significantly more water than half-round styles. Oversized 3x4-inch or round downspouts are essential to move the water quickly away from your foundation.
Unlike aluminum gutters that come with seamless options, vinyl gutters are only available in sections. As a result, they're more likely to leak. The average life span for vinyl gutters is about a couple of decades because of their weather sensitivity. Aluminum gutters can better withstand adverse weather conditions.
Brass is the most widely recognized material that should not be used for modern gutter systems. While highly decorative, brass gutters are incredibly heavy, expensive, and reactive to environmental elements, making them a poor practical choice compared to standard metal alternatives.
Some studies show that people exposed to high levels of aluminum may develop Alzheimer's disease, but other studies have not found this to be true. We do not know for certain that aluminum causes Alzheimer's disease. Some people who have kidney disease store a lot of aluminum in their bodies.
Seamless gutters typically cost $8 to $28 per linear foot installed. While more expensive than sectional systems (averaging $3 to $20 per linear foot), they reduce leak risk and require less maintenance over time. Pricing varies based on material, home height, and accessibility to your roofline.
Many new homes are built without gutters primarily to cut construction costs, as builders assume buyers can add them later. However, they may also be omitted intentionally if the home features deep, extended roof overhangs, perfectly sloped natural grading (the slope of the yard), or if it is located in an arid climate where heavy rainfall is rare.
Look/Style
The wider the fascia, the smaller the gutter will look. So, if your fascia is 1”x6” you are most likely going to install 5-inch gutters. If your fascia is 1”x8” or 1”x10” you are going to need 6-inch gutters to keep everything looking proportional.
Clean your one-story-high gutters right from the ground with an old paint roller on an extension handle. It's angled just right to push leaves and debris out quickly and easily.
LeafFilter faced a major nationwide class-action lawsuit ( Zilinksky v. LeafFilter North, LLC) regarding false advertising and a defective gutter guard system. The lawsuit alleged the product failed to prevent debris buildup and actually clogged, causing homeowners to deal with overflowing water and expensive cleanup costs.
Ideally, gutter replacement should occur during mild conditions for both ease of installation and system performance. Spring and Fall: These seasons typically offer moderate temperatures and lower precipitation, making them the most favorable times for installation.
Downspout alternatives replace or augment standard metal drainpipes. Top options include decorative rain chains that guide water into basins, rain barrels for water harvesting, French drains and dry wells for below-ground dispersal, or grading/bioretention to let water sheet naturally away from your foundation.
A good rule of thumb for downspout spacing is at least every 30 to 40 feet. If you want to play it safe or get a lot of torrential rain, err on the side of caution and install downspouts every 25 feet.
Top 11 Best Gutter Alternatives for Your Home
Removing your downspouts for winter can cause damage
This may not seem like an issue on the surface, but when water has no downspout and sits in the pipe to freeze and expand, it can cause cracks in the gutter materials.
When building a house, the most expensive phases can be broken down into three primary cost drivers: interior finishes (which often make up the largest single chunk of the budget), followed closely by structural framing and the foundation.
Is New Siding, Insulation, or Gutters Tax Deductible? In most cases, replacing siding, insulation, or gutters is not tax-deductible as a home improvement. However, certain upgrades that improve energy efficiency may qualify for federal tax credits under the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit.
Having gutters installed is a smart investment to protect your home from foundation damage, roof leaks, and landscaping issues. Lowe's offers professional gutter installation services, with costs typically ranging from $1,000 to $6,300, depending on the size of your home and the type of gutters you choose.
The most common concern about aluminum in antiperspirants and other topical products is that it's linked to breast cancer. However, there's little evidence that typical exposure to aluminum causes cancer or any other health condition.
Aluminum is a recognized neurotoxin that penetrates the blood-brain barrier and is eliminated extremely slowly, with an estimated half-life of 7 years in the brain. It impacts the central nervous system by inducing oxidative stress, promoting brain inflammation, and impairing neuronal function.
Although it was initially believed to primarily affect the nervous system and bones, aluminum toxicity is now known to impact the cardiac, pulmonary, reproductive, gastrointestinal, and hematological systems. Symptoms include anemia, pulmonary fibrosis, and decreased bone density.