What is the difference between old and new cast iron skillets?

Author: Jay Barton  |  Last update: Thursday, May 29, 2025

Myth 6: Vintage is Better Than New The Reality: The material may be the same, but the production methods have changed. In the old days, cast iron pans were produced by casting in sand-based molds, and then polishing the resulting pebbly surfaces until smooth. Vintage cast iron tends to have a satiny smooth finish.

How can you tell a good quality cast iron skillet?

  • Look for a smooth and shiny surface: A well-seasoned cast iron pan should have a smooth and shiny surface.
  • Check for a dark color: Cast iron that has been seasoned properly will develop a dark color, often black or deep brown.
  • Check for a non-stick surface: A well-seasoned cast iron pan should have a non-stick surface.

Do cast iron skillets get better with age?

Like I said, nearly indestructible. And unlike any other cookware, cast iron improves with age. With each use, the cooking surface becomes more smooth, allowing oil to seep into the surface and continually improve the seasoning (or as some like to call it, the patina).

When should you throw away a cast iron skillet?

The more you use a rusted pan, the more iron you'll consume in your food. It's best to avoid cooking with a rusty cast iron pan. If it's reached the point of corrosion or deep rust, throw it away rather than risk your and your family's health.

What is the best grade of cast iron?

V-2 (class 40) Gray Iron, ASTM B48:

V-2 is ideally suited for straight wear applications and possesses the highest strength, hardness, resistance to wear and heat treat response for an unalloyed gray iron.

How to Identify Antique and Vintage Cast Iron Skillets

What is the number 1 cast iron skillet?

Final Verdict. If you're looking for cast iron that ranked highly across the board, check out the triple-seasoned Lodge Cast Iron Blacklock Skillet. For a budget option, we recommend the Lodge Cast Iron Skillet, which performed well and is lightweight, making it incredibly user-friendly.

What are the three types of cast irons?

The 4 Types of Cast Iron
  • Grey Cast Iron.
  • White Cast Iron.
  • Ductile Cast Iron.
  • Malleable Cast Iron.

Do you wash a cast iron skillet after each use?

Immediately after cooking with it, hand-wash and scrub your cast-iron skillet clean. "Simply wash the cookware with hot water and a nylon brush," suggests Stubblefield. "Use a little soap if you need it."

What is the lifespan of a cast iron skillet?

With proper care cast iron cookware can withstand a lifetime of use. Actually several lifetimes as these cast iron pans and dutch ovens are often passed down from generation to generation. Taking care of cast iron cookware is as easy as 1 – 2 – 3.

How to tell if cast iron is bad?

If a crack appears in your cast iron pan, it's time to ditch it. Even a hairline crack will expand and contract when heated and cooled, and ultimately the pan will split—a potentially dangerous situation if it happens during cooking! Plus, cracks are difficult to clean and may harbor bacteria and rust.

What ruins a cast iron skillet?

You let your skillet soak.

Soaking your cast iron skillet in your sink is a recipe for rust, as is washing it in the dishwasher. Instead, clean it ASAP, even using simple soap and water if you must.

How much should a cast iron skillet cost?

The price of the skillets we tested ranged from $18 to $350.

Can you put a cast iron skillet in the freezer?

The Enameled Cast Iron surface is non-porous and is suitable to use for storing raw or cooked food in the refrigerator or freezer.

What is #1 cast iron?

Grey cast iron is characterised by its graphitic microstructure, which causes fractures of the material to have a grey appearance. It is the most commonly used cast iron and the most widely used cast material based on weight.

How to spot a fake cast iron skillet?

How can you tell if a pan is cast iron or a fake?
  1. Feel the weight. Pick up the pan and feel the weight. ...
  2. Check the bottom of the pan. There should be a manufacturer logo marked on the pan, often with the stock number or city it was manufactured in.
  3. Check for rust. ...
  4. Check the handle. ...
  5. Check the pan's surface.

Should cast iron be shiny or dull?

Some cast-iron skillets, including those made by Lodge, come pre-seasoned. You'll notice they have a smooth, non-greasy, softly lacquered surface. Those that don't come pre-seasonsed have a matte gray finish—until you season them, at which point they become shiny and closer to black in color.

How to tell a good cast iron skillet?

Features to Look for in Cast Iron Cookware
  1. Handles: Check on the cookware's handles. ...
  2. Thickness and weight: In general, with cast iron, the thicker and heavier it is, the better. ...
  3. Quality of enamel coating: If you're buying a cast iron pan that's enameled, make sure that the enamel is high quality.

How often should I oil my cast iron skillet?

You should only need to fully re-season your cast-iron cookware one to two times a year, but you may also want to give it some extra seasoning love anytime you cook something that requires a heavy-duty cleaning.

What should not be cooked in cast iron?

What to Avoid Cooking in Cast Iron
  1. Highly Acidic Foods (Like Tomatoes) Over time, cooking with oils and fats continues to build a pan's seasoning; cooking with acidic foods can erode that seasoning. ...
  2. Delicate Fish. ...
  3. Eggs.

Can you use olive oil on cast iron?

You can generally use whatever oil you prefer, as long as the cooking temperature is below the smoke point of the oil. Olive oil, vegetable oil, sunflower oil, and grapeseed oil are all great multipurpose cooking oils—you can use them for everything from sautéing to baking.

Why can't you wash cast iron with soap?

Decades ago, soaps were made with lye and vinegar, and they were too harsh for use on cast iron pans. They would indeed strip away oil and could remove seasoning. But today's soaps, especially ones that are made with eco-friendly solutions, are often too mild to remove seasoning.

What is the difference between old cast iron and new cast iron?

Smooth Cooking Surface

Food does seem to release better on an old pan. A cast iron pan with a smooth finish is particularly beneficial for cooking omelets and scrambled eggs over the pebbly finish on new pans.

Which cast iron pan is the best?

The Lodge 10.25-Inch Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet has proven time and time again to be the best overall cast iron due to its unrivaled consistent heating at a stellar price.

What is the difference between GREY and white cast iron?

Carbon Content: Grey cast iron has a lower carbon content (2.5%-4%), whereas white cast iron has a higher carbon content (above 2%). Properties: Grey cast iron offers good machinability, wear resistance, and damping capacity, while white cast iron is extremely hard, brittle, and wear-resistant.

Previous article
How much does it cost to replace copper with PEX?
Next article
Does vanity go on top of laminate flooring?