Removable agitators are excellent "two-in-one" options if you need the flexibility to switch between deep-cleaning heavily soiled clothes (using the agitator) and gentle, spacious washing for bulky items like comforters (removing the agitator to use an impeller). However, they may not clean quite as aggressively as traditional fixed agitators.
A washing machine with a removable agitator is a smart choice if your laundry needs vary from week to week. It offers the flexibility to switch between powerful agitation for heavily soiled clothes and a spacious, open drum for bulky or delicate items like bedding, activewear, and comforters.
10 Most Reliable Top Load Washing Machines
Removing an agitator opens up space in the wash tub. As a result, it is easier to clean bulkier items like comforters. In addition, you can fit more clothes in the machine and get laundry done faster.
If you prioritize shorter cycles and deep cleaning for heavily soiled clothes, an agitator machine is a great option. However, for delicate fabrics, bulky items, or efficiency, a non-agitator washer may be the better choice.
A washing machine with an impeller uses less motion and water than a washer with an agitator. Designed so laundry has more room to move, it drives clothes from the outer rim of the wash basket to the center, using a small amount of water to optimize the friction. This is what helps deliver a gentle, yet thorough clean.
On the short end, the washers to avoid will last around seven years (or less) and are prone to repairs during that time. On the high end, reliable washing machines can last more than 15 years, well beyond their expected timelines.
Yes, you can wash a comforter in a top-load machine with a center agitator, provided the comforter fits loosely in the tub with enough room to move. If the comforter is packed tightly, it won't get clean and can get damaged.
Neither system is universally better; the choice depends on your cleaning priorities. Agitators clean faster and are superior for heavily soiled, large loads, while impellers offer gentler, more water-efficient cleaning that is better for delicate items and provides more space for bulky items.
A 2-in-1 removable agitator is a feature on top-load washing machines that allows you to physically add or remove the center post. It essentially gives you two different types of washers in one machine:
The Electrolux 700 Series ELFW7737AT front-load washer is widely considered the top overall machine available. It earns the number one spot in industry and expert evaluations due to its class-leading energy efficiency, exceptional stain-removal capabilities, spacious capacity, and a highly accurate cycle countdown timer.
Neither brand is universally "better." Bosch is generally superior for longevity, quiet operation, and premium European styling. LG often wins on cutting-edge smart technology, innovative features, and price-to-performance value.
Choosing between GE and LG washers depends on your specific laundry needs. Generally, LG is better for front-load machines, fabric care, and advanced tech, while GE excels in smart connectivity, bulky item handling, and top-load performance.
When searching for a washing machine with a removable agitator, Whirlpool is the only major manufacturer that offers this specific 2-in-1 technology. Their patented removable agitator models provide the ultimate flexibility: leave the agitator in for standard, heavily soiled loads, or remove it and swap in an impeller to wash large, bulky items like comforters.
For the least amount of mechanical issues, Speed Queen is universally praised as the most reliable brand due to its heavy-duty, commercial-grade build. For modern, feature-rich machines, LG consistently ranks at the top for front-load reliability, and Whirlpool/GE are top choices for traditional top-loaders.
For a homemade option, you can try cleaning your washing machine with vinegar. Just pour two cups of distilled vinegar into your detergent drawer. You can also use soda crystals (or baking soda) to clean your washing machine. Sprinkle half a cup into your drum and then let your washing machine run on a hot setting.
The purpose of a removable agitator is to provide a versatile, two-in-one washing experience by giving you the heavy-duty cleaning power of a traditional spindle alongside the spacious, gentle cleaning of an impeller.
The Best Agitator Washer Brands Fred's Recommends
Yes, you can absolutely use vinegar and baking soda to clean your washing machine. This safe, natural method breaks down detergent buildup, removes musty odors, and helps prevent mold.
If your washing machine isn't cleaning clothes properly or the center column isn't moving during a cycle, your agitator may be broken. To diagnose the problem, unplug the machine, check for physical obstructions, and test the agitator’s movement and internal parts.
Choosing between a Maytag impeller and a Maytag agitator depends on your laundry habits. Agitators use a tall center post to physically rub clothes, providing superior stain removal for heavily soiled items. Impellers use a low-profile disc that spins to create water currents, which is gentler on fabrics, saves water, and accommodates bulkier items.
Because of their gentle washing motion, impeller washers may not always get rid of deep dirt and stains like an agitator washer. Impellers may tangle or twist your laundry. During high spin speed cycles, clothes can get twisted in the center of the wash load, throwing off the machine's balance.
Use a large capacity washer and dryer. Your comforter needs room to agitate and tumble – it can't get clean otherwise. A large capacity washer is typically one with at least 5.0 cu. ft.
Washing A Down Jacket
The good news is that most down jackets can be washed in a front loading washing machine or a top loading washer without an agitator. (Unfortunately, agitators can damage down filling.)
To wash a queen-size comforter at home, you need a large-capacity washing machine of at least 4.5 cubic feet. Anything smaller risks damaging the motor, overloading the machine, or leaving the comforter soapy and uncleansed.