How do I know which element to replace on my water heater?

Author: Jaren Farrell  |  Last update: Friday, March 14, 2025

The replacement element must be the same voltage and wattage as the element being replaced. Never exceed the nameplate rating on the water heater. Check the nameplate on the heater to determine the proper voltage/wattage combination is correct for your heater.

How do I know which water heater element is bad?

To test the element, you must measure its resistance. Switch the multimeter settings to measure resistance and place the nodes on the two screws. A functioning heating element should read between 10 and 30 ohms. The heating element is broken if the meter reads 1 or 0.

How do I know which heating element to replace?

Factors to Consider When Buying a Heating Element

Wattage - The wattage of a heating element is one of the most important factors to consider. This will determine how much heat the element can generate and how quickly it can heat your desired area. Make sure to pick an element with a wattage appropriate for your needs.

Are all hot water heater elements the same?

No, all electric hot water heater elements are not universal. There are three main types of elements: screw-in, bolt-in, and clamp-in. Elements also come in different wattages and voltages. It is important to choose the correct element for your water heater, or it will not work properly or may even damage the heater.

Should both water heater elements be on at the same time?

Only one element will come on at any one time. This is known as a flip/flop system. On a 240 volt water heater, there will always be 120 volts to both elements. The thermostat will direct the second leg of the 120-volts to the element to complete the 240 volts required to energize the element.

How to Replace an Electric Water Heater Element

Why don't I have hot water after replacing element?

"Replacing A Heating Element"

It may take several hours for a newly installed electric water heater to reach normal operating temperature. If you don't have hot water after two hours (water not even warm), first check to make sure the water heater is getting electrical power.

Does the top or bottom element heat first?

The upper element heats the water in the top portion of the tank first. Once the top portion reaches the desired temperature, the upper thermostat switches power to the lower element, heating the rest of the water. This dual-element design ensures a more efficient heating process and a steady supply of hot water.

How do I know what size heating element I need for my water heater?

Check the nameplate on the heater to determine the proper voltage/wattage combination is correct for your heater. Unless your heater is small you will probably need a 240v element.

Can I replace a 3500 watt element with a 4500 watt element?

A 3500 watt unit will allow 12 gauge wire with a 20 amp breaker. There are thousands of old homes that do not have 10 gauge/30a circuits, therefore, 3500 watt elements are changed out for 4500 watt at installation or water heaters are sold with 3500 watt elements.

Why won't the pilot light stay lit on my gas water heater?

Your water heater requires air to keep the pilot light burning. Otherwise, the flame goes out. Ensure that the water heater is not surrounded by clutter, lint, or debris to increase the amount of combustible air. Keep the surrounding area as clean as possible.

Can you change a hot water element without draining the tank?

Can you change a water heater element without draining the tank? No, you'll need to drain the tank before changing a water heater element, as the water heater element sticks through the side of the tank and uses a gasket to prevent water from pouring out.

Which water heater element runs the most?

If so, they are configured that the upper element always runs more than the lower element. This is because the lower element cuts on only after the upper element cuts off. And the upper element always comes on first because hot water exits from the top.

What are the symptoms of a bad thermostat on a hot water heater?

Signs Your Water Heater Thermostat Is Faulty
  • You have no hot water.
  • You're running out of hot water quickly.
  • The water is too hot.
  • It takes a long time for your water heater to heat the water.
  • You keep having to reset the high-temperature limit switch.

How much does it cost to replace a heating element in a water heater?

Water heaters have a few different parts; based on data from HomeGuide, here are some average prices to replace common components: Dip Tube: $100 to $300. Heating Element: $100 to $350. Anode Rod: $150 to $350.

What is the life expectancy of a hot water heater element?

That varies with the location and design of the unit, quality of installation, maintenance schedule and water quality. If your water heater is more than 10 years old, leaks around the base of the tank or operates erratically, it's probably time to replace your water heater.

Why does my hot water heater keep tripping the reset button?

The high resistance caused by a loose wire produces a substantial amount of heat that can eventually cause fires. If there is a loose electrical connection within your water heater's system, your reset button's thermometer can trip (regardless of the water's temperature) if it picks up the heat from that loose wire.

How do I know which heating element to buy?

It's important to know the size, length, diameter, and lead length of the heater required. These factors are important for designing heaters and addressing design limitations that may arise, such as maximum allowable watt density for the style or application of the heater.

Can I put a higher wattage element in my water heater?

Higher wattage elements can lead to increased energy consumption, particularly if used inappropriately. A 5500 watt element may heat water faster but might not always be the most efficient choice for your household size. Conversely, a 4500 watt element can be more energy-efficient if your hot water demand is moderate.

Can you burn out a water heater element?

As you just found out, even a few seconds of dry firing an electric water heater can burn out your water heater element.

How do I know what element my hot water heater is?

After opening the heater, locate the heating element. It should look like a rectangle or cylinder with wires and screws on either side. After locating the heating element, test the element's electrical resistance with a multimeter. A working heating element should have a resistance between ten and 32 ohms.

Are top and bottom water heater elements the same?

The parts for dual-element water heaters are not interchangeable, meaning there are different replacement parts for the top and bottom elements.

Are most water heater elements universal?

There are three types: screw in, bolt in and clamp in. They all have different wattage ratings and can work on either 120 or 240 voltage. Check your state and local codes before starting any project.

Should both elements on a water heater be set at the same temperature?

Adjust both thermostats to the same temperature setting. WARNING! Higher temperatures increase the risk of scalding.

Is 130 too hot for a water heater?

The maximum Department of Energy recommended water heater temperature setting you should never exceed is 140 degrees Fahrenheit. The lowest recommended setting should never be below 120 degrees Fahrenheit.

What happens if too much sediment is in a water heater?

Sediment buildup in your water heater can be a major problem. Not only will it reduce the amount of hot water you have for cooking, cleaning, and bathing, but it can also damage your water heater and shorten its serviceable lifespan.

Previous article
Are there any problems with vinyl plank flooring?
Next article
Will coffee grounds stop up a septic tank?